|
76. In addition to the rabbinical students from Morristown, groups
of four young women student-teachers
from a Chabad teachers seminary in Israel are in Dnepropetrovsk
on practice teaching assignments. One group is in Dnepropetrovsk
from October through January, the second from February through May.
They teach most of the Judaica classes at the day school and also
teach classes to local young Jewish women on Sundays. Their supervisor
is Chana Kaminetzky, Rabbi Kaminetzky’s wife.
77. The Dnepropetrovsk
Jewish Day School appears to be thriving, enrolling more
than 650 students in grades one through eleven. Early registration
figures for 1984-1985 indicate that the school will educate 800
pupils next year, the maximum number that can be accommodated in
its current facilities. Construction still under way when a Boston
group visited the city in October 1993 has been completed. A large,
well-equipped kosher kitchen
(with some equipment provided by JDC) serves over one thousand meals
every day, more than seven hundred to pupils and staff at lunch
and more than two hundred at breakfast. Rabbi Kaminetzky believes
that this kosher dining facility is the largest in all of central
and eastern Europe. In addition to a spacious dining room for students,
several smaller rooms accommodate groups of more modest size. The
cost of maintaining this service is a major burden; the Ukrainian
government pays for the lunches of children in the first four grades,
but older pupils must buy their own meals—and many families
cannot afford to give their children lunch money. For now, the school
provides all students with lunch, but Shmuel is not sure that the
free lunch program can continue indefinitely. He would like a Boston
sister-city relationship to consider an ‘adoption’ program
in which Boston-area Jews would ‘adopt’ a needy student,
paying a small monthly sum that would cover lunches (approximately
fifteen cents each day) and certain other expenses.
The second, smaller building that was serving as
construction materials warehouse during our October visited has
also been completed. It now houses a large and small auditorium,
an activities room, a large and small gymnasium, a library, a book
storage room, and classrooms for the yeshiva
high school, the program for approximately thirty boys that
offers an extended day with much more religious instruction than
is provided in the regular day school.22
Rabbi Kaminetzky expressed disappointment with
his inability to obtain computers
for the school. He had hoped that JDC would supply computer equipment,
but that agency has so far evaded his request. He is pursuing other
potential sources (which he did not identify).
Betsy Gidwitz was present at (and addressed) a
“directors’ day”
at the school, a meticulously planned event in which directors (principals)
of several dozen schools in the city as well as municipal and regional
education officials attended a day-long program at the school. The
fifty visitors viewed both secular and Judaic studies classes in
the elementary and secondary divisions, heard explanations of the
school’s goals and objectives, discussed curriculum and other
issues with day school teachers, ate lunch (doubtless the best school
lunch in the city) in the new dining room, and watched/listened
to a performance of Jewish songs (most in Hebrew, some in Yiddish)
and dances by groups of pupils ranging in age from first to eleventh
graders. Following the musical presentation, different guests stood
to comment on what they had seen; without exception, the remarks
were positive, sometimes adulatory. The visitors praised the high
caliber of teaching, the breadth of curriculum, the visible happiness
of the children,23
and the pride the children felt for their Jewish heritage. Several
of the speakers acknowledged prior antisemitic prejudice, apologized
for their bigotry (which, they said, had been based on ignorance);
now that they had learned more about Judaism, Jewish history, and
the importance that Jews attach to education and sound upbringing,24
they would no longer tolerate anti-Jewish bias. Each visitor was
given a menorah and candles (provided by JDC). |
Rabbi
Kaminetzky reported that nine attendees called on the following
day to ask if one or more of the day school choirs would perform
at their schools and/or if a day school teacher or Rabbi Kaminetzky
himself would visit their school to teach about Judaism. An education
official in the oblast (region
encompassing Dnepropetrovsk, several other large cities, and a number
of towns and villages) also called, asking if the program could
be repeated for teachers in the oblast
outside Dnepropetrovsk as some of them were even less informed
about Judaism than those who lived and worked in Dnepropetrovsk
itself. Rabbi Kaminetzky and the day school principal, Semyon
Isaakovich Kaplunsky, were delighted at the response. The
program had been initiated at the suggestion of the chief education
inspector of the oblast, a
non-Jewish woman who has been assisting the school in upgrading
its secular curriculum.25
Rabbi Kaminetzky and Mr. Kaplunsky had readily agreed, realizing
that school principals could influence teachers and pupils in their
attitudes about Jews.
78. A delegation from the Lishkat
haKesher has recently visited the city to explore possibilities
of opening a second day school
(under the Lishka Maavar program).26
This group, which included Zvi
Gruman, the director of the Israel Cultural Center in Dnepropetrovsk,
attempted to gain permission for such a school from municipal education
authorities and from the deputy mayor of the city by declaring to
them that the religious orientation of the existing day school is
so overpowering that it offends many parents and that the existing
day school is biased in that it does not accept children of mixed
marriages.27
The second charge is blatantly false and the first appears to be
equally untruthful because (a) the Judaic component of the curriculum
is deliberately limited in scope so as not to alienate parents whose
outlook has been shaped by decades of forced secularization under
Soviet domination, and (b) persistently high enrollment figures
suggest strong parental satisfaction with the school. The aggressive
and fallacious Lishka approach angered municipal education officials
and the deputy mayor who have their own stake in the success of
the school because they have worked with it since its inception,
have encouraged city financial support for it, and have developed
strong relations with Rabbi Kaminetzky, Principal Kaplunsky, and
others associated with the school. The officials were also embarrassed
by the spectacle of bellicose Jews denouncing other Jews.
Flustered, the officials mentioned that a particular
school building might become available in the near future. The Lishka
delegation subsequently entered the still-operating school without
invitation, “inspected” the facility, and informed its
startled principal that the Lishka might operate it in the future.
The unauthorized exploratory tour caused an uproar in the school
and generated a hostile report in a small newspaper in Dnepropetrovsk.
When Rabbi Kaminetzky heard that a larger, more respected newspaper
was investigating the matter and intended to publish an equally
critical article, he intervened with the newspaper’s editor
to prevent its publication. As of mid-May, the Lishka attempt to
open a Maavar school in Dnepropetrovsk remained unfulfilled.
79. Betsy Gidwitz also visited the Jewish
preschool, which has finally relocated to larger quarters
that can accommodate about forty children between the ages of three
and six. The school has its own kosher kitchen and a fence-enclosed
playground. Chani Kaminetzky
and the wives of Rabbis Chaim Ber
Stambler and Meir Stambler
are all involved in its management as are other women. Rabbi Kaminetzky
would like to open additional preschools in other areas of the city.
80. The Chabad summer
camp expects to enroll 160 children between the ages of ten
and sixteen during each of three 22-day sessions. Because the camp
is one of very few in the post-Soviet Union actually owned by the
Jewish community (rather than leased),28
the Joint Distribution Committee
is seriously considering developing it into a facility that can
be used the entire year for seminars, winter camping, etc. A city-owned
construction company (Dneprograzhdanproyekt)
has organized plans for winterizing current buildings and erecting
new structures; if approved by JDC in Jerusalem, work may begin
in August or September. The camp property covers fifty-five hectares
(approximately twenty-three acres) and is located on the Samara
River in Novo-Moskovsk, an easy drive from Dnepropetrovsk.
81. The new Jewish
Agency station in Dnepropetrovsk will also conduct a summer
camp in 1994. Located in the same general region as the Chabad
camp, the JAFI facility is leased from a formerly successful factory
that operated it as a Pioneer camp for the children of its employees.29
The camp will accommodate 200 youngsters between the ages of ten
and seventeen in each of three two-week sessions30
Individuals who have seen both the Chabad camp and the JAFI camp
describe the latter as significantly larger and in better condition.
The leased JAFI property has two swimming pools. Campers will be
drawn from Dnepropetrovsk and Zaporozhe oblasts.
Local counselors for this camp and for another JAFI camp near Kharkov
will be trained at the Dnepropetrovsk-area camp in a common pre-camp
training session.31
82. The Joint Distribution
Committee has recently opened an office in Dnepropetrovsk
from which it serves Jewish population centers in Dnepropetrovsk
and Zaporozhe oblasts. Shimon
Strinkovsky, who previously served the area through monthly
visits from a base in Moscow, is now living in a Dnepropetrovsk
hotel until more conventional housing can be arranged.32
The JDC office itself consists of one room that accommodates Mr.
Strinkovsky, several local staff (including Jan
Sidelkovsky, an exceptionally competent local man who has
long been engaged in Jewish communal work), and various equipment
and supplies. Because of overcrowding, the atmosphere is often chaotic;
when Mr. Strinkovsky is present, the chaos is accompanied by a thick
cloud of cigarette smoke that never dissipates. |

22. This
program is described in two previous reports, Visit
to Jewish Communities in Ukraine and Moscow and Related Meetings
in Jerusalem (Cambridge: the author, October 1993) and Dnepropetrovsk
Kehilla Project: Background Information (Cambridge: the author,
February/March 1994).
23. One
commented that children were ordered to smile for visitors during
the Soviet period, but the smiles that she had seen that day were
undeniably natural and heartfelt.
24. The
speakers used the Russian word vospitaniye
for which no English equivalent exists. Vospitaniye
encompasses the concepts of moral education, cultivation of skills
in community life, exemplary social conduct, etc. Use of this word
(and many others) was corrupted during the Soviet era to mean upbringing
according to communist ideology.
25. The
inspector is close to retirement age. After she leaves her current
position, she will join the day school faculty as a consultant in
teaching methodology and (secular) curriculum planning.
26. The
Lishkat haKesher sponsors or co-sponsors eleven day schools (Maavar
schools) in the post-Soviet successor states (including one in nearby
Zaporozhe) and 125 Sunday schools (Mechina schools). It works closely
with the Israeli Ministry of Education in this effort. The schools
vary widely in quality.
27. Day
schools in the post-Soviet successor states that are sponsored by
religious movements differ in their policies on accepting children
of mixed marriages. Whereas the Dnepropetrovsk school has always
accepted such children, drawing no distinction between children
whose mother or whose father is Jewish, Rabbi Bleich’s day
school in Kiev gives clear preference to children from endogamous
Jewish marriages and next to children whose mother is Jewish, effectively
restricting enrollment to children who are halachically Jewish.
28. The
legal owner of the property is the governing board of the Chabad
synagogue in Dnepropetrovsk.
29. The
Pioneer organization was a more-or-less compulsory youth group for
Soviet schoolchildren. It was directed by the Komsomols, the young
adult division of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
30. As
noted earlier, all JAFI camps will be operating short seasons in
1994 because a strike by university professors in Israel during
the winter is forcing Israeli universities to extend the academic
year into the summer, thus reducing the amount of time available
to Israeli students for camp counseling.
31. When
Rabbi Kaminetzky was informed that the Jewish Agency would also
operate a summer camp in the Dnepropetrovsk region, his response
was, “Ten camps are not enough. There can never be enough
Jewish summer camps.”
32. While
in Kiev, the JDC group in which Betsy Gidwitz participated encountered
a Jewish physician from Florida who had just come to Kiev from Dnepropetrovsk.
The physician had met Mr. Strinkovsky there and was quite upset
to discover that he was residing in ‘“luxury hotel accommodations”
that, according to the physician, cost $68 per day. The physician
was aware that JDC is funded by UJA -- and he clearly viewed this
expenditure as misuse of UJA money. He subsequently recorded his
ire over this circumstance in a written report that has been circulated
in the Union of Councils [formerly the Union of Councils for Soviet
Jews] network. In a conversation in Kiev, Betsy Gidwitz told the
physician that Mr. Strinkovsky had been living in the hotel for
a few months while trying to find a suitable rental apartment ---and
that such apartments are not readily available. Further, the hotel
is hardly luxurious. The physician was not interested in hearing
another view, as his anger then and his subsequent written report
prove. While in Dnepropetrovsk, Betsy Gidwitz met with Shimon Strinkovsky
in his office and in the hotel suite, the latter consisting of two
very standard Soviet-era rooms that could not reasonably be termed
luxurious. If JDC is actually charged $68 a day for this suite --
Betsy Gidwitz did not check the figures -- that price is consistent
with charges for other accommodations (for foreigners) in the same
hotel. Both Rabbi and Chana Kaminetzky and the Nechushtans of JAFI
lived in hotels for several months after their arrival in Dnepropetrovsk.
|
|
|
|
|